Image default
Community

NCRC’s piece “In Richmond, Virginia, gentrification is colonization”

The National Community Reinvestment Coalition recently published an opinion piece that has gone viral. It is about gentrification in Richmond and even more locally, the East End. Here’s how it starts:

Like many urban areas, my neighborhood was designed to fail.

Home to nearly 2,000 of Richmond’s 3,255 public housing units, the city intentionally created a concentrated pocket of poverty in the East End. In fact, according to the former CEO of Richmond’s housing authority, the neighborhood has the highest concentration of public housing per square mile south of Baltimore. And while Richmond is divided into nine districts, 60 percent of the public housing units fall within just one: the East End. This means that there is only one city council member and one school board representative for an area with a disproportionate percentage of the city’s poor, greatly limiting their power and influence within the city’s political landscape.

However, while poverty does deeply impact financial status, it does not determine social and cultural wealth or the capacity of a person for greatness.

My family’s story directly reflects this reality


[sep]

This is a pretty well written piece about the current state of development in the East End. On one hand, urban redevelopment may provide benefits to the new and existing urban residents. We all love seeing the before and after homes that are being revitalized. Key word here is “revitalized”.


Is it possible to have gentrification without displacement? Maybe, but only if the total number of housing units increases while maintaining the number of lower-priced units. Responsible urban development is key and we hope many in the neighborhood keep that in mind. It is also important that YOU voice your opinion- go to the Church Hill Civic Area Association meetings, go to the CAR meetings and participate in the discussion.

We hope that we can agree that most neighborhoods can benefit from new residents, regardless of cultural background, provided that they are committed and involved in their community.

Check out these articles:

Everything was something else

The impacts of gentrification on food insecurity

[sep]

The National Community Reinvestment Coalition and its grassroots member organizations create opportunities for people to build wealth. We work with community leaders, policymakers and financial institutions to champion fairness in banking, housing and business.

Related posts

Gentrification in Richmond

Jacob C.

Heads up: Planned Power Outage Church Hill North

Jacob C.

Ground breaking at old Armstrong High School Site

Gustavo
avatar
24 Comment threads
13 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
23 Comment authors
Steven SwarthoutDubois2Randall EgginkCNLiz Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Dyvonne King
Guest

There’s no benefit to getting priced out of your neighborhood!

Lori Dachille
Guest

I agree. I moved here from Brooklyn where I was born and raised. In many parts of NYC it started with “gentrification “ then it became unaffordable for everyone, taxes, housing, everything. Community involvement from everyone is essential to prevent that from happening here.

Lucia Urban Bakewell
Guest

Love Church Hill…wish I could move there!

Dionna Dawn
Guest

Why choose the quote you did to share the story? The real importance of this piece is the part about how gentrification IS colonization when it is irresponsible urban development. The rents here are outrageous and going up all the time…while racial tensions grow deeper and deeper.

Thomas J. Alleman
Guest

The public housing is a trap. It should also benefit from redevelopment. Slavery by another name is what most of the black community faced here and everywhere they moved. Even when moving North. Now people from mostly the North are coming here but with money and although the East End is vast, infilling, restoration, renovation of homes is going on, it is almost always for the benefit of the White people moving in. How would you feel if you were black and saw no renovation for you? No better oppertunities or a better situation at all but higher taxes? Granted… Read more »

Lucia Urban Bakewell
Guest

it is not without a lot of problems but the communty spirit, and natural beauty and history make it a good place for people to work together to overcome the sad past.

arthur Burton
Guest
arthur Burton

Having lived through most of the new revitalization, the (about 30 years) facts of how it all started were not accurate.

jean mcdaniel
Guest
jean mcdaniel

So much of what is posted on this subject and on this web site is lacking in historic narrative. I am not qualified to fill in All the blanks, but I offer a small snippet. In the 1960.s many governing bodies idea of urban renewal was the heavy use of a bulldozer. The closest example of that is the area across from Stone Berwery all the way past Broad Street. This area used to have houses just like the present ones in the “historic district” of Church Hill. The “historic district” of Church Hill was facing the same type of… Read more »

UH Neighbor
Guest
UH Neighbor

The author distinguishes between south and north parts of the East End to make an important point backed by statistics. I think it’s misrepresenting this (well written) piece to suggest that she is trying to further divide. Instead, she explains how “the border of affluence is shifting further and further north, displacing low- to moderate-income black families with each transitioning block.”

Gustavo
Admin

That’s a great point UH Neighbor, I edited the comment. In no way was I suggesting the author is trying to further divide. If you saw the amount of commentary about the “otherness” of the divide between Church Hill and “Church Hill North” and the “projects” then I guess I was trying to inelegantly make a point about language used by some folks on the internet.

Wendy Gayle March
Guest

They should knock them down. They are shoddy with nightmare upkeep issues. They are hotbeds of crime where often the innocent are harmed. New solutions should be explored including technical training programs for employment and betterment

MamaSense
Guest

Two sides of the same coin: Blacks who could afford to, moved to the subdivisions. That’s because homeowner loans were easier to acquire than loans to renovate.
The increased Black influence in surrounding counties -eastern Henrico especially- is the flip-side of the coin.

Tonya N. Jefferson
Guest

MamaSense I’ll have to throw in my personal family story about suburban black influence and real estate. I grew up in eastern Henrico, but my parents decided to move us to Midlothian, VA which is in Chesterfield County into a community with its own country club, golf course, swimming pools, jogging/ bike trails, etc. simply to increase our educational opportunities. My parents kept the house in the East End of Henrico for nearly 40 years. My parents had some blueprints drawn to enlarge the Henrico County home, but decided to purchase a newly constructed second home instead. My parents have… Read more »

UH Neighbor
Guest
UH Neighbor

Thanks for the thoughtful reply, Gustavo!

MamaSense
Guest

Tonya N. Jefferson; Excellent! Parents availed themselves of the options presented to them. And obviously they could afford to do so.
Many homeowners and their children either, couldn’t afford to renovate, or was advised to buy a home in a subdivision with attractive terms.
Now those houses are being restored, and a neighborhood reflecting those new owners has been established.
Having grown up in the east-end, I see those houses friends lived in years ago, and how they’ve been renovated block after block.
And I see old friends who are now ‘intruders’ on the block they grew up on.

Tonya N. Jefferson
Guest

MamaSense I believe that is the case with some homeowners. I had an elderly relative pass away earlier this year who lived in Church Hill. She made sure she stayed in her community.

SA Chaplin
Guest
SA Chaplin

Shekinah Mitchell’s complaint is personal: she finds it increasingly difficult to afford where she would like to live —the east end. And the overall focus of her article is on race. Am I the only person offended by this? I hope that one day Ms. Mitchell will judge by content of character rather than color of skin.

Omari Kadaffi Guevara
Guest

Funny how numerous warehouses in Richmond get renovated and turned into luxury lofts while people still believe the narrative being sold to them that similarly constructed public housing is shoddy and needs to be torn down. Yet you dont see any sinking foundations or severe structural damage. HUD inspects fairly regularly. Free your mind.

MamaSense
Guest

Tonya N. Jefferson; God bless her soul. I’m sure she received offers for her residence, but didn’t see any wisdom in uprooting from there.
What puzzles me now is, access to loans targeted for renovation/restoration have been relaxed, where before, a mortgage for a subdivision house appeared more sensible than renovation/restoration. A reversal of fortunes.

Tonya N. Jefferson
Guest

MamaSense Sometimes the homeowner doesn’t know his or her options. A HELOC could be used for homeowners with equity wanting to do repairs. Lenders vary as well for refinancing options. So which mortgage type are you comparing to the 203K- ARM, fixed, 2/1 buy down, etc. and at what interest rate?

BAF
Guest
BAF

There are no simple solutions to this. As areas improve and revitalize, property values increase. If you own property, that’s a positive–unless the increases in taxes make your now-higher valued property unaffordable. That’s a basic problem with property taxes–they are income blind. If you live in a house that has been in your family for generations, but your personal assets are meager, you may have to sell the family house because of rising taxes. There might be value to counter that by limiting tax increases on properties held and lived in (no investments) for a period of time–let’s say 20… Read more »

Dave Gorman
Guest

Seriously ? “Gentrification is colonization ?” Is the writer of this article smoking crack ? Does everything, everything, have to have a racial undercurrent to it ? If as a white guy I enjoy Cheerio’s or a plain white bagel for breakfast…is my breakfast racist ? Stop the dumb*ss insanity already. Thank the developers with vision who risk capital to better your neighborhood. Thank them for the eventual allied roadway, sidewalk, street lighting, and other improvements that typically accompany their developments. Thank them for the brave, adventurous entrepreneurs who also risk capital and set up businesses that employ your whining… Read more »

BAF
Guest
BAF

BTW, never knew I was a colonist. Where do I get my musket and tri-corn hat so I can join the militia? The Red Coats are coming!

MamaSense
Guest

Tonya N. Jefferson; HELOC: COULD’VE, but probably wasn’t. Many who abandoned homes and neighborhoods they grew up in couldn’t resist those similar terms and lower interest-rates for a subdivision house.
They were easier to buy than restoring our parents 4-bedroom, 2-3 bath, attic and basement cribs.
Now, the interest-rate(s) for renovation/restoration loans are lower than mortgages.
It wasn’t always that way.

MamaSense
Guest

Lori Dachille; maybe too late! This is financially driven -where did these funds originate? Well, $6-billion ‘disappeared’ in Iraq. Remember?

Thomas J. Alleman
Guest

Dave Gorman it is not about investment, it is about being forced out due to higher and higher taxes.

MP
Guest
MP

One thing people don’t mention much is that a lot of the newcomers are black, too. I live in a mostly renovated block, and more than half the newcomers are black. Are they “colonizers” or do “gasp” people actually move houses and neighborhoods in the course of their lifetime? I believe you are allowed to live somewhere other than the neighborhood you’re born in.

Another thing, How are we supposed to get to the beloved community if people like this author complain if people not like her move next door?

Dionna Dawn
Guest

Dave Gorman move out of the neighborhood? Where? To the bus bench on the sidewalk outside the new apartment building that costs $1400/ month for an 800 sq ft apartment? I suppose that’s exactly what you mean.

Dionna Dawn
Guest

I live in one of these “new” apartment buildings and the management agency here is terrible. Building bigger buildings and charging more for rent doesnt improve a neighborhood.

Susan Haas
Guest

What an exciting time for Richmond. A new and diverse population is filling urban areas with a mix of incomes and uses, ingredients for a robust and resilient social fabric. It is true Richmond is famous for “red-lining”. Geographic boundaries were drawn leaving those inside w/out economic and social resources. The lack of adequate education compounded the problem that exists today. I encourage Richmonders to understand this part of our more recent history and how shaped our city and families w/in it.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining

Liz
Guest
Liz

This is one of the comments in response to the article. I copied and pasted in its entirety as I thought it an excellent response. “Gentrification is surely a major trend in the east end, but I think it is a fallacy to blame it on “white people” “from the past.” You only have to look at what’s going on today, in the moment. Richmond has the most punitive, regressive utility rates and taxes in the region, and that squarely falls on the shoulders of the less affluent of whatever race. And going up. That alone is a gentrification accelerator.… Read more »

CN
Guest
CN

Dave Gorman and BAF you seem to be perpetuating the suppressive colonial mindset. These developers are all white, not respectful of these peoples property value and won’t contribute to any of these communities. These developers live in all white, expensive homes , and spend the money that they continually rape from these communities in their privileged communities. The solution is to assist minorities to keep their homes and be able to compete economically for a place at the table. Disparity in employment, communities, education, and then discrimination has become so tremendous in Richmond and other cities that without legal and… Read more »

Randall Eggink
Guest
Randall Eggink

CN, yeah, sure, all the blame goes to the evil white developers who’ve changed Church Hill from a forsaken wasteland into a dynamic, destination neighborhood. I guess I’m one of those developers. I bought a home on 26th, five blocks north of Broad, in 2005. I pumped thousands of improvements into it and cashed out in 2018, and have invested in a smaller property six blocks further north on 27th. I redeveloped ONE (1) home, and scores of others like me have done the same. I’m a retired City of Richmond employee. I’m not rich, but I’m white. And I’m… Read more »

Dubois2
Guest
Dubois2

CN Lying doesn’t make it so. There are a number of major (and mom and pop) developers of color working in CH. Last I checked 2 of the biggest flip companies were owned and run by black men. It’s been a couple years, but I doubt that’s changed. In CH as it was, the “inheritance” of a house was a very small amount of money, clearly outweighed in many if not most cases by deferred mantainence costs. (A 30k house needing 20k in foundation repairs and a 15k roof) If you can take the heat, meaning live with a set… Read more »

Steven Swarthout
Guest
Steven Swarthout

On rising taxes: California passed Prop.13 years ago which freezes your taxes at the rate they were when you bought your house. It stopped the problem of rising home values forcing people to sell because they could not afford to pay the taxes. Something to consider.

CN
Guest
CN

Unfortunately the people who are victimized in CH don’t have the financial voice to be heard on how they were affected by your benevolent deeds Randall. Dubois your facts are way off. Not worth me dissecting that dribble.

Randall Eggink
Guest
Randall Eggink

CN, what the hell is a “financial Voice”, and who appointed you to speak for those affected by the improvements developers have implemented in Church Hill? The City has been rebricking sidewalks all over the neighborhood since the houses started selling like hotcakes in 2017. Do you think Mayor Stoney is displeased to reap all the property taxes generated by dozens of $300K homes? He wants even more and its why he’s paving the alleys and restoring the sidewalks. Get a grip — this is not a black and white racial issue. Its an exercise in basic economics. Church Hill… Read more »