Image default
Food

Mike & Maddy’s (Formerly Anthony’s on the Hill)

I had the pleasure of stopping by Mike & Maddy’s today.

This was the first day of business for the new concept by owner Michael Calogerakis. Mike & Maddy’s resides in the space formerly occupied by Anthony’s on the Hill at the corner of 29th & Broad St. I had a bagel sandwich called the Broad St BLT, amazing medium roast coffee, and I got to try a vegan muffin and some coffee cake.

All of the food was incredible! This is something we don’t really have on the hill right now and it’s very affordable!

The muffins and cakes are made in-house, the bagels are from Cupertino’s Bagels in the west end, and they have a whole list of locally sourced ingredients.

The fare is breakfast oriented with bagels, smears, and breakfast sandwiches. Michael told me that the menu will change and evolve as he learns more about what customers are looking for.


I also had to ask about the name Mike and Maddy’s while I was there. The Mike is obvious but he shared with me that Maddy is his daughter. She helped him design the logo and contributed to the concept and some menu ideas. Michael also shared with me that his entire team had a part in the menu and picking what they’re serving so hopefully it has a little bit for everyone.

I definitely came away impressed by the quality of everything I had at Mike and Maddy’s and definitely recommend you stop by.

You won’t be disappointed.

What: Mike & Maddy’s – Coffee, Bagels, and Breakfast Sandwiches
Where: 2824 E Broad St, Richmond, VA 23223
When: Tue – Fri 7a to 2p, Sat & Sun 8a to 1p, Closed Mondays

Related posts

Frontier by Alamo Now Offering Lunch!

Kiet Vo

Meet Adriana from Tree’s Tacos and Tips

Gustavo

Former Noma chef brings scratch cooking to Armstrong

Church Hill People's News
avatar
25 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
25 Comment authors
nadineBrunoEric S. HuffstutlerJessica ShookGrace Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Edward Baldwin
Guest

It would be cool if they made pizza.

Tanya Zebroski
Guest

Theres enough pizza places thank goodness for something different!!

Lauren Marie Rodgers
Guest

So excited for a breakfast spot on our block, welcome!!

MP
Guest
MP

I know some people were sad about Anthony’s closing, but THIS LOOKS AMAZING! Cupertinos bagels are the best in town, and I love love love breakfast bagel sandwiches 🙂 So excited! We definitely didn’t have something like this yet in Church Hill and I will be stopping by often on the weekends, esp. when I have guests!

UH Neighb
Guest
UH Neighb

I wish them the best of luck! I’m also dismayed to see the disposable products in the photos with this article. Would love to see traditional reusable restaurant dishes — as well as more of a sit-down, dine in menu, like good old eggs, toast and potatoes, etc. We can already get good egg sandwiches and muffins around the corner.

Brett Feinstein
Guest

Can we get the eggs and such without the bread for us keto types?

Sarah Holloway
Guest

Why is everything in Church Hill closed on Mondays?

Resident
Guest
Resident

Menu item says “churchill” is it named after something other than our neighborhood? Exciting news tho.

Running Dog
Guest
Running Dog

Good to see they have reopened, hopefully they will add some good omelets to the menu. Not a bread person.

Gina Fendley
Guest

Let’s go!!

Joyce Moller Fendley
Guest

Gina Fendley I miss the pesto so much

Mark
Guest
Mark

Meh. Pizza was better. This seems wasteful and the selection is limited. Just want a ham egg and cheese..

ian
Guest
ian

Glad to see bagels join the pie place, the muffin and biscuit place (WPA), and the pasty and bread place (Sub Rosa) as Church Hill baked options. Still a bit sad to lose one of the only neighborhood delivery options for dinner though.

Leslie Harris
Guest

We weren’t fans of their pizza but we LOVE a good breakfast. ???
Hope they have much success. ?

Maurice
Guest

Okay everybody that’s it. We need to close this place up since it doesn’t cater exactly to Mark’s preference of ham egg and cheese and nothing else.

Although I’m willing to bet he likes some whine with that.

Mister F
Guest
Mister F

Completely agree that lower carb options would be a huge addition to the neighborhood – tired of cooking eggs at home.

Casey
Guest
Casey

A breakfast option in Churchill?!?! What a refreshing idea!!!

Dania Jennison
Guest

Had their “Old School” sandwich yesterday. Soft toasted brioche, perfectly cooked egg, cheddar cheese, crispy bacon with a maple aoili. A fantastic sandwich. Rostovs dark brew was a bit too light/weak for my needs ( i need a little punch in the mouth by my coffee). All in all, a good visit.

K
Guest
K

Reading these comments is a constant reminder of how privileged our neighborhood is becoming. Sometimes a business chooses to reinvent itself because they are passionate about something. As a neighborhood that prides themselves on community and supporting local business we should uplift new business not make judgement without even trying it. “Meh. Pizza was better. This seems wasteful and the selection is limited. Just want a ham egg and cheese..” You know a great idea to get a ham, egg, and cheese? Go in and buy something else you might like and maybe ask them if it’s something they could… Read more »

Friendly Neighbor
Guest
Friendly Neighbor

“We definitely didn’t have something like this yet in Church Hill,” someone said. Did everyone forget Captain Buzzy’s is literally right down the street with a bigger menu and that there are no other GOOD pizza places nearby?

Grace
Guest
Grace

Agree with K. Cut them some slack.

K
Guest
K

8 1/2 has good pizza. Also if you are willing to use Grubhub or Uber eats there are over 10 Pizza places that deliver and the majority are locally owned and operated. That includes pizza from Triple Crossing Fulton. I’d venture to say it’s not an issue of availability but taste.

Jessica Shook
Guest

Added menu item: Punch in the morning–locally sourced by cashier. WHAM!

Eric S. Huffstutler
Guest
Eric S. Huffstutler

8 1/2 has horrible pizza… all bread, no toppings, soggy, and we need pepperoni. I am a New York kind of pizza guy (thin crust with lots of cheese and meat). Anthony’s did have good pizza. I am more of a Blue Plate traditionalist when it comes to breakfast (think Cracker Barrel). Hoping they will expand their fare to include cook to order eggs, grits, hash browns, buttermilk biscuits, etc… and not just bagels or gluten-free sandwiches 🙂 Was hoping for more of a “3rd Street Diner” sit and eat concept here in Church Hill instead of grab and go.

Bruno
Guest
Bruno

Congratulations to M&M. A really nice addition to the hood. Good sandwiches, nice crew and a great way to start the day. Try it out – you’ll meet your friends.

nadine
Guest
nadine

Eric Huffstutler, I have to agree. The dough is not right at 8 1/2. It is missing something, maybe salt? I dont know, but the crust is bland, the toppings do not excite me, and it is super expensive.

Have not tried Mike and Maddy’s, but I am excited.